A Think Again Media Group publication
Everyone Believes

Is water from a private well safer than public water?

Private well safety: the measurements behind the source

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Everyone Believes

Private well safety: the measurements behind the source

Private well safety depends on measurements and maintenance, not on whether a household owns the source. A U.S. Geological Survey investigation sampled about 2,100 private wells across the country and found one or more contaminants at concentrations of potential health concern in about 23 percent. Most sampled wells did not have such concentrations. The result leaves room for both findings: private wells can supply usable water, and private ownership does not establish that a particular supply is free of harmful contamination.

In a March 2009 interview preserved by USGS, scientist Leslie DeSimone explained that the contaminants most often reaching concerning levels largely came from aquifer rocks and sediment. They included arsenic, uranium, radon and manganese. Nitrate at high concentrations was more often associated with human activities such as fertilizer and septic waste. Some contaminants varied by geology; others reflected land use. Even a well in a mostly undeveloped area could contain naturally occurring substances of concern. A quiet setting and a deep underground source do not remove the need to identify what the water contains.

The federal legal distinction begins with the system, rather than its public or private owner. Under the Safe Drinking Water Act's definitions in 42 U.S.C. §300f, a public water system supplies water for human consumption through pipes or other constructed conveyances and has at least 15 service connections or regularly serves at least 25 people. A community water system serves the specified number of year-round residents or residential connections. The word public therefore describes a category of service. It does not mean that every system covered by the law must be municipally owned.

The same section defines primary drinking-water regulations as applying to public water systems and addressing contaminants that may adversely affect health. Those regulations can specify a maximum contaminant level or a treatment technique, together with testing, quality-control and operating requirements. The legal framework concerns dependable compliance, rather than a general preference for water from one kind of landscape. An individual domestic well falls outside this federal public-system framework. Private well safety consequently relies on a different arrangement for obtaining evidence about the household's supply.

The evidence required from community systems includes a Consumer Confidence Report. Section 300g-3 calls for reports describing the water source, detected regulated contaminants, relevant limits and compliance information, including corrosion control. It also provides for reporting violations and explains terms such as action level and maximum contaminant level. These are concrete disclosures that customers can examine or request. They connect the water delivered by a system with measured results and regulatory requirements, instead of relying on a general statement that the supply has been treated.

The statute does not treat the detection of any substance as identical to a health emergency. It requires an explanation that the presence of contaminants does not necessarily mean drinking water poses a health risk. Concentration, the applicable standard and the particular substance matter. The reporting provisions also distinguish annual information from notices about failures and violations. Oversight creates duties to test, disclose and respond; it does not mean a regulated system can never have a problem. That distinction is more useful than assuming either public water or well water is automatically superior.

For household wells, the University of Georgia's Testing for Water Quality recommends annual checks for total coliform bacteria, nitrate, total dissolved solids and pH, with additional tests guided by suspected contaminants. It recommends further testing after events such as flooding near the well, damage to the wellhead, nearby chemical spills or repair work. A local laboratory, health department or Extension specialist can help match testing to the location. A previous result supplies a baseline, but a damaged well or changed surroundings can justify a new sample before the next routine test.

Sampling itself follows a protocol. UGA's water laboratory guidance directs households to obtain the correct containers and instructions before collecting water. Some analyses need water that has stood in the pipes; others require flushing first. Microbiological samples use special containers, must avoid contamination from hands or bottle interiors, and have holding-time requirements. These differences explain why a casually filled bottle is not interchangeable with a properly collected laboratory sample. Private well safety includes the quality of the evidence: the laboratory needs a sample suited to the substance or organism being measured.

A regulated supply can also change between the treatment plant and a household faucet. UGA identifies plumbing, connections and home treatment equipment as possible sources of contamination and notes that lead can enter water from older plumbing materials. Its guidance therefore allows for household testing even where the source is a public system. The relevant chain runs from source through distribution and household pipes to the point of use. For wells, the homeowner must arrange that scrutiny; for public supplies, system reports provide an additional record. In either setting, specific results support a response matched to the actual problem.

True or False?

Public water is sketchy; a private well is the pure, unregulated good stuff.

Show the answer

The Record

The testing requirements tell a different story. Under the Safe Drinking Water Act, a public supply has to be regularly tested and treated if necessary to meet EPA standards — and you can call your water company for the Water Quality Report/Consumer Confidence Report to check. A well, especially if old or poorly built, can become contaminated. Test it at least once a year, and again if something seems off. The tap with paperwork beats the tap on the honor system.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Everyone Believes’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.