Piranesi's imaginary prisons: a changing world of stone
Giovanni Battista Piranesi's imaginary prisons were architectural inventions printed on paper. His Carceri series depicts enormous underground spaces, crowded with vaults, stairs and machinery. The Getty describes them as etchings of imaginary prisons, rather than records of an existing penal institution. The first published group contained 14 etchings. Giovanni Bouchard issued them around 1749–1750, beginning a publication history in which Piranesi repeatedly changed the darkness, detail and extent of the series.
The Getty Research Institute preserves a first edition and first issue dated 1749–1750. Its collection includes a complete, uniform set of Piranesi's work and a selection of early states. The prisons sit within a print collection that also covers views of places, maps, and architectural ornament. Piranesi later reworked the original plates and added two more, bringing the sequence to 16 prints. The physical history of an impression therefore includes more than its original composition. The same copperplate could produce an earlier image and then a revised one, allowing Piranesi to alter the imagined architecture before printing it again. The series changed through that process of revision as well as through the addition of new scenes.
Piranesi also worked with actual ancient monuments. The Getty's account of his career describes more than 1,000 etchings of Rome and its antiquities, alongside archaeological studies and forceful arguments about architecture. His activities included documenting remains, publishing views and advertising antiquities sold through his studio. One spectacular image of Trajan's Column used six copperplates to make a print nearly nine feet high. Its representation even restored the ancient bronze emperor at the summit, replacing in the image a later figure of Saint Peter. An identifiable monument could thus become the subject of a reconstruction as well as a detailed view.
The same Getty exhibition examined Pier with a Lamp, dated 1749. In that prison composition, arches spring from a massive support and extend toward destinations that remain out of sight. Interwoven etched lines intensify the sense of movement in the architecture. The museum described pillars and arches seeming to twist with muscular energy. Its account connected the work's visual force with the restless marks across the surface. Even where the individual architectural elements appear solid and familiar, their arrangement makes the imagined interior unstable and difficult to encompass.
The Kunstbibliothek of the Berlin State Museums traced another influence on these imaginary prisons: the theatre. Piranesi, a Venetian who settled permanently in Rome in 1747, worked amid the visual culture of elaborate stage settings. Eighteenth-century scenographers had developed dramatic effects of illumination and perspective, and he incorporated such effects into his architectural visions. Berlin's account associates his work with the angled stage architecture known as scena per angolo. This approach directed attention along oblique views instead of arranging the entire scene around a single central vanishing point.
For the Carceri, the Berlin interpretation connects that angled construction with theatrical lighting and themes drawn from contemporary drama. It also identifies names of an ancient emperor's victims cut into masonry in the second plate, relating those inscriptions to the period's stage villains. Elsewhere in his work, Piranesi produced maps, diagrams and reconstructions that circulated among scholars. He joined London's Society of Antiquaries in 1757 and became an honorary member of Rome's Accademia di San Luca in 1761. The architectural fantasies developed alongside this recognized archaeological career.
A surviving example of Plate XI in the British Museum is dated 1761 and measures 405 by 550 millimetres. The museum's description distinguishes its increasingly elaborate architecture from the loose handling of the first edition. A complex arch enters the composition from the left. Beyond the bridge and arches in the middle distance, additional vaults and stairways continue deeper into the interior. Their fine detailing and pale, silvery appearance contrast with the heavy areas of shadow. The museum treats those changes as evidence of Piranesi's substantial reworking of his earlier copperplates. The British Museum also describes tiny figures set beneath the towering architecture, with staircases apparently continuing without an exit. Cables, pulleys and levers suggest threatening machinery. In these imaginary prisons, the small human presence supplies a scale against which the immense built spaces become still more imposing.
Berlin's Kupferstichkabinett holds The Big Wheel, dated around 1761–1762. Curator Dagmar Korbacher describes the sequence's title page as explicitly presenting flights of fancy. Her interpretation emphasizes the artist's experiments with etching and his manipulation of surfaces, space and perspective. Technical impossibilities within the buildings coexist with a powerful expression of confinement and suffering. The designation of these spaces as imaginary prisons was therefore part of their presentation, even while their masonry, mechanisms and depth gave them a compelling visual presence. Across the series, the apparently monumental world remained an invention realized through the changing marks of printmaking.
- J. Paul Getty Museum, The Magnificent Piranesi — www.getty.edu
- Getty Research Institute, Prints—Special Collections: first edition and first issue of the Prisons, about 1749–1750 — www.getty.edu
- Kunstbibliothek, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, The Piranesi Principle, on Google Arts & Culture — artsandculture.google.com
- British Museum, Giovanni Battista Piranesi, Carceri, Plate XI, an etching, on Google Arts & Culture — artsandculture.google.com
- Dagmar Korbacher, Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Carceri d'invenzione: The Big Wheel, on Google Arts & Culture — artsandculture.google.com
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Title Page, from Carceri d’invenzione, about 1749–1750, catalogue on Google Arts & Culture — artsandculture.google.com