A Think Again Media Group publication
Everyone Believes

A fire with an unusual pattern

Wick effect: a photographed fire and the fuel beneath it

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Everyone Believes

Wick effect: a photographed fire and the fuel beneath it

The wick effect acquired unusually direct evidence in woods near Medford, Oregon, in February 1991. Two hikers found a woman's body still burning. A responding deputy photographed the low flames before extinguishing them. J. D. DeHaan and M. Scanlan described the investigation in the California Association of Criminalists' spring 1996 publication. The woman had been stabbed, and the circumstances were investigated as a homicide. This was a scene with injuries, clothing, leaves, photographs, and a still-active fire, rather than an unexplained patch of ash discovered long after everything had stopped burning.

The investigators reconstructed a wick effect involving rendered body fat absorbed into charred clothing and the leaves beneath the body. The surrounding woodland had not caught fire. Their proposed small quantity of charcoal starter fluid remained uncertain: laboratory tests for an accelerant were negative, and direct ignition of clothing was another possibility. A sighting of the woman alive about five hours before discovery bounded the burning time at less than five hours. That contemporary limit differs from later retellings assigning a much longer duration. The mechanism and the uncertain initiating fuel were separate findings.

The basic transport process is visible in Michael Faraday's candle demonstrations. In The Chemical History of a Candle, he placed a porous salt column in colored, saturated salt solution. Liquid climbed the column even though the solution could not dissolve more salt. He then described fuel rising through a piece of cane, which could be lit at its upper end. Both demonstrations separated the reservoir of liquid from the porous structure conveying it. The wick effect likewise depends on fuel reaching a burning region through an absorbent material; the wick and the stored fuel perform different jobs.

Faraday also distinguished liquid fuel from the vapor entering a flame. In another demonstration, a tube collected combustible material from the dark interior of a candle flame. Material taken from a region where combustion had finished behaved differently. His candle therefore involved successive physical and chemical changes: melting, movement through the wick, vapor production, and burning in contact with air. Applied to a wick effect fire, the relevant comparison is the continuing delivery of fuel after ignition. A candle demonstration establishes that delivery principle, rather than identifying what started any particular fatal fire.

A later synthesis on Wikipedia describes an experiment associated with a 1963 Leeds investigation. Human fat wrapped in cloth was heated with an external burner. It took about a minute to establish burning; after the burner was removed, combustion progressed slowly through the roll for about an hour, producing smoke and soot. That description supplies a small-scale example of sustained burning after an outside heat source was withdrawn. It should remain distinct from the Oregon scene: the laboratory material was deliberately prepared, while the clothing, leaves, and injuries in the woodland were evidence from an actual death investigation.

The same synthesis describes a larger demonstration made for BBC television in 1998. A pig carcass was wrapped in a blanket in a furnished room and externally ignited. Burning continued for hours with low flames and limited damage around the carcass. Heat collected at the top of the room and melted a television. The wick effect did not require all furnishings to burn together. Heat accumulating in the upper room and flames spreading outward to neighboring objects represent different patterns of fire damage, even when the same fire supplies the heat.

The November 2009 fire-debris training plan hosted by NIST treats several relevant variables separately: fuel form and geometry, conduction, convection, radiation, ignition, smoldering, flaming, and room-fire development. It also distinguishes heat release rate from fuel load. A large quantity of combustible material and the rate at which it releases energy are different properties. The plan includes the wick effect among the properties of ignitable liquids and specifically assigns evaluation of an ignition source's competence. A proposed fuel pathway consequently belongs alongside ignition and heat-transfer analysis in a reconstruction.

The same training document identifies several reasons a debris sample can test negative for an ignitable liquid. None may have been present, or a liquid may have evaporated, burned away, or been lost through poor packaging. It also identifies contamination during suppression, handling, or laboratory preparation as a concern. A negative result therefore describes the submitted sample under its testing conditions. It leaves the initiating circumstances dependent on the rest of the investigation, rather than making an undetected accelerant either certain or impossible.

Later forensic literature continues to examine the surrounding configuration. An Interpol review covering 2019–2022 describes a separate outdoor case in which clothing acted as a wick and a tree trunk contributed a chimney effect. It also summarizes a death in which autopsy findings indicated lethal hypothermia before a later fire. The review treats these as separate investigations with different circumstances. A wick effect can explain continuing combustion and uneven damage; it does not, by itself, establish whether a person was alive when burning began or determine the cause of death. Those conclusions require the medical and scene evidence together.

The Question

What mechanism can sustain a fatal fire through clothing and body fat after an outside flame starts it?

Show the answer

The Answer

The wick effect. Porous fabric can carry liquid fuel toward a flame, sustaining a localized fire after an external ignition. The process can continue while fuel and oxygen remain available.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Everyone Believes’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.