A Think Again Media Group publication
Everyone Believes

If water looks clear and tastes fine, is it safe to drink?

Drinking water safety: what a clear glass cannot show

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Everyone Believes

Drinking water safety: what a clear glass cannot show

Drinking water safety cannot be established by a clear glass and a pleasant taste. Michigan's Statewide Drinking Water Advisory Council states that dissolved lead has no detectable color, taste or smell. A certified laboratory must test the tap water to establish whether it contains lead. The metal can enter from pipes and faucet components, so an apparently ordinary glass can contain contamination acquired during delivery. Appearance describes one property of the water; it does not measure the concentration of a dissolved metal.

Flint's 2015 records show why specific measurements matter. The Flint Water Advisory Task Force's March 2016 findings document an April 27, 2015, message confirming that Flint's treatment plant lacked corrosion-control treatment. On the same date, EPA specialist Miguel Del Toral visited resident LeeAnne Walters to inspect plumbing and deliver sampling bottles. The concern involved water chemistry interacting with pipes. It required inspection and sampling, rather than a visual judgment about the source or the finished water.

The task force's timeline then tracks separate sets of results. On August 27, 2015, Marc Edwards released findings from 48 samples, with 30 percent above 15 parts per billion of lead. By September 8, a larger Virginia Tech effort had results from 252 samples, including 101 above 5 parts per billion and several above 100. Those numbers describe the submitted samples, not a census of every home. On September 24, Mona Hanna-Attisha presented findings of increased elevated blood lead levels in children after the water-source change. Water samples and blood tests supplied different evidence about contamination and exposure.

Hanna-Attisha explained the public-health concern in testimony to Congress on April 13, 2016. She connected inadequate corrosion control with lead moving from plumbing into drinking water and into children's bodies. She described lead as a neurotoxin with consequences extending beyond the immediate exposure and emphasized prevention. Her testimony addressed people already exposed, alongside the need for a long-term response. Drinking water safety therefore involved both stopping an environmental source and supporting the health of the community affected by it.

The same hearing also acknowledged that Flint residents had experienced visible and sensory problems. Water-system specialist Stephen Estes-Smargiassi discussed complaints about changed color and unpalatable water, and the importance of investigating them. Flint does not establish that contamination always arrives without a warning. It shows that complaints deserve attention while laboratory results establish details that the senses cannot supply. A change in appearance can prompt an investigation without identifying the contaminant, and an absence of such a change cannot establish that lead is absent.

Arsenic supplies a separate, naturally occurring example. The National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences describes dissolved arsenic as tasteless, colorless and odorless. Water can acquire it through contact with particular rocks and soils, and concentrations can vary between nearby wells. The institute's 2023 fact sheet reports that USGS analyzed more than 5,000 wells and found at least 7 percent above the public-water standard of 10 micrograms per liter. Those measurements concern a particular contaminant and sampled wells. A neighboring well's result cannot replace testing the supply actually used by a household.

The health concern also has its own evidence. NIEHS identifies arsenic as a human carcinogen associated with several cancers and describes risks from prolonged exposure. Its guidance says testing is necessary to detect arsenic in solution. Boiling, chlorine-bleach disinfection and ordinary water softening do not remove it. Treatment must be suitable for arsenic rather than selected because it makes water seem fresher. The fact sheet directs households toward appropriate removal methods and local health guidance. A process useful for one water problem may leave this dissolved contaminant behind.

The University of Georgia's Home Water Quality and Treatment makes the same distinction across treatment methods. Mechanical filtration removes particles such as sediment; activated carbon commonly addresses unpleasant tastes, odors and some organic contaminants. Disinfection methods address microorganisms. Reverse osmosis uses a membrane to remove inorganic contaminants and some organic chemicals. These methods perform different tasks. No single treatment system removes every possible bacterium, chemical and mineral, so a more agreeable taste after treatment does not establish that every relevant hazard has been addressed.

UGA also calls for continuing maintenance and testing of treated and untreated water according to professional or manufacturer guidance. Contamination can change, and treatment performance does not remain fixed indefinitely. Point-of-entry equipment treats the household's incoming supply, while point-of-use equipment treats water at a selected outlet. The location and purpose of a device therefore affect what its performance means for a particular glass. Drinking water safety depends on identifying the problem, choosing a suitable response and checking the water after that response.

For lead specifically, Michigan's guidance recommends filters carrying certification for lead reduction and particulate reduction, used and replaced as directed. It advises using cold water through the filter and states that boiling will not remove lead. These are measures tied to a named contaminant and documented plumbing pathways. They have a more specific purpose than improving flavor or clarity. The visible water can look unchanged while the relevant concentration changes, which is why laboratory measurements remain necessary to establish what is coming from the tap.

True or False?

Contaminants can affect health even when drinking water looks clear and tastes fine.

Show the answer

The Record

Plenty of contaminants don't change how your water looks or tastes. They can still affect health even when the water looks clear and tastes fine. Testing offers information that taste alone cannot supply.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Everyone Believes’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.