A Think Again Media Group publication
Everyone Believes

A cherished English vessel with a longer journey

Edenhall glass: a medieval beaker and its English legends

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Everyone Believes

Edenhall glass: a medieval beaker and its English legends

The Edenhall glass takes its name from an English house, but the V&A places its manufacture in Egypt or Syria around 1350. Its orange-tinted glass carries arches, vines and split-palmette leaves in red, blue, green and white enamels outlined in gold. The beaker became known as the Luck of Edenhall centuries after its medieval manufacture.

Its route to Cumberland is undocumented. The V&A notes a trade in Middle Eastern enamelled glass through Venetian merchants, without identifying this vessel's journey. A fitted leather case was probably made in France or England less than a century later. The glass belonged to the Musgraves of Eden Hall; its name appears in Sir Philip Musgrave's will of 1677.

The identification of its origins has its own scholarly history. Charles Hercules Read discussed the vessel in a study of medieval enamelled glass published in Archaeologia in 1902. He cited an illustrated volume of verse issued by Beilby Porteus in Carlisle in 1856. Porteus's notes had treated the object as Venetian glass intended for use as a chalice. Read described that identification as a popular theory. He also suspected that the volume's illustration, advertised as a drawing by Porteus, had actually been taken from an earlier published picture rather than from the vessel itself.

Read examined another description, in the Cumberland volume of Magna Britannia by the Lysons brothers. That publication pictured the cup and its leather case, interpreting the case's foliage and sacred lettering as signs of a religious purpose. Read was unconvinced. He considered the leaves conventional trefoils and thought neither the ornament nor the monogram necessarily indicated sacred use. The Edenhall glass had accumulated an explanation based partly on its later container. His discussion separated the interpretation of the case from the identity and original function of the glass inside it.

John Pagen White's Lays and Legends of the English Lake Country offers a different kind of evidence: an extended literary treatment of the vessel's supernatural reputation. His verse introduces a radiant lady arriving from overseas, who presents the glass to a young Musgrave at St. Cuthbert's Well. Later, a butler interrupts fairies attempting to loosen it from the sleeping man's hand. The imagined gift connects the family's prosperity with the survival of its cup. This is a narrative about the beaker's reputation, rather than documentation of its medieval manufacture or arrival in Cumberland.

White's accompanying notes preserve further versions and attributions. They repeat an identification as Venetian glass of the 10th century, an attribution the V&A does not share. They also describe a tale in which a butler surprises fairies dancing near the spring and takes the vessel. In another passage, White recounts a supposed accident involving the Duke of Wharton and a butler who catches the falling glass. These competing episodes belong to the later literary record surrounding the Edenhall glass; they do not supply a documented chain of ownership from its workshop.

Ludwig Uhland turned the vessel's reputation into a catastrophe in his ballad of 1834, translated into English by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. A young lord summons the cup at a banquet and challenges its fragility. When the goblet breaks, the hall also splits apart, flames erupt and enemies enter. The lord dies holding the broken vessel, while an elderly butler searches the ruins. The final speech expands the imagined collapse of one household into a meditation on the eventual collapse of the world. The shattered goblet belongs to Uhland's dramatic invention: the museum's surviving medieval beaker remained intact.

A recollection of actual hospitality appears in Thomas Adolphus Trollope's What I Remember, published in 1887. Trollope had first met Sir George and Lady Musgrave after travelling to Penrith in 1839. His brother-in-law took him to Edenhall from the nearby town. When Trollope and his mother later lived at Penrith, he remembered the Musgraves as friendly neighbours. He recalled Sir George showing the glass to visitors and insisting that they handle it. In his account, Musgrave regarded exposure to possible breakage as part of submitting to luck; simply locking the vessel away would remove that element. Trollope also included a footnote about Musgrave's reported disagreement with Longfellow over the poem's ending. The owner objected to a literary conclusion in which the cup had been broken. This memoir describes a later owner's attitudes, not the circumstances of the medieval object's creation.

The Edenhall glass was loaned to the V&A in 1926 and acquired in 1958. Eden Hall was demolished in 1934. The medieval vessel survived the house that gave it its English name.

The Question

The V&A attributes the manufacture of the Luck of Edenhall to which region?

Show the answer

The Answer

Egypt or Syria. The V&A dates the enamelled beaker to around 1350, centuries before its documented association with Eden Hall.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Everyone Believes’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.