A Think Again Media Group publication
Everyone Believes

Orbits around black holes

The orbit of S2: a star that keeps coming around

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Everyone Believes

The orbit of S2: a star that keeps coming around

The orbit of S2 carries a star around the dark central object in the Milky Way without taking it through the event horizon. Its path has been followed across decades, including close approaches and the turn back outward. This is a moving star with measured positions and velocities. The observing teams have used that motion to estimate the central mass and test gravity. A black hole can have orbiting companions, and S2 supplies a particularly detailed example of what motion outside the boundary of escape looks like.

In 2002, Rainer Schödel and colleagues reported 10 years of high-resolution imaging that traced roughly two-thirds of the star's path around Sagittarius A*. Their observations included its nearest and farthest passages. They fitted a bound, strongly elongated orbit with a period of 15.2 years and a nearest distance of 17 light-hours. The inferred enclosed mass was about 3.7 million solar masses, with substantial uncertainty. The important geometry was a return path: the star moved around a compact concentration of mass rather than making a single plunge toward it.

The team used the orbit to examine alternatives to a central black hole. Their measurements excluded a cluster of ordinary astrophysical objects and a proposed concentration of massive fermions with high confidence. Those conclusions came from the compact mass required by the motion. They were not photographs of the event horizon. The central object's properties were inferred through an independently visible companion, making the star's trajectory both an example of orbital survival and a tool for investigating what lay inside it.

By 2018, the GRAVITY collaboration described the orbit of S2 as taking about 16 years. Its May 2018 close approach brought it within roughly 120 astronomical units of Sagittarius A*, about 1,400 Schwarzschild radii. Its speed there reached approximately 7,650 kilometers per second. The collaboration combined measurements of motion across the sky with radial velocity, the component toward or away from the observing direction. Earlier instruments supplied a long baseline, while GRAVITY combined light from four telescopes to sharpen the measurements near the crucial passage.

The 2018 result also concerned the star's light. The team detected the combined gravitational redshift and transverse Doppler effect expected from relativity. Their fitted relativistic contribution agreed with the predicted value within the reported statistical and systematic uncertainties. A simple Newtonian treatment did not reproduce those data. The star's continuing orbit could therefore be recognizable as a long ellipse while its light carried measurable effects beyond the simpler gravitational model. Orbital survival and strong gravitational effects occurred together in the same observations.

A further result followed in 2020. GRAVITY reported Schwarzschild precession: a shift in the orientation of the orbit of S2. The data showed an advance of about 12 arcminutes per orbital period, consistent with general relativity. For this highly elongated path, the effect appeared mainly as a change between the incoming and outgoing directions around closest approach. The analysis used 2017–2019 GRAVITY measurements along with earlier positional observations. Continuing to track the star after its close passage was essential to identifying the outgoing direction.

That experiment distinguished a slowly turning orbit from an exact repetition of the same closed ellipse. Its fitted precession parameter was 1.10 with an uncertainty of 0.19, where general relativity predicts 1. The team also constrained any extended mass within S2's orbit to less than roughly 0.1 percent of the central mass. Those are specific findings about the observed trajectory and mass distribution. They do not imply that every possible path near a black hole remains outside it, or that an orbit must be perfectly unchanging to persist.

NASA's explanation of a hypothetical replacement Sun gives the larger principle. If the Sun were replaced by a black hole with the same mass, the planets would retain their orbits because the gravitational influence at their distances would remain the same. Sunlight would disappear, with disastrous consequences for life, but the orbital paths would not automatically collapse inward. NASA also makes clear that the real Sun will not become a black hole. Its future is a white dwarf. The replacement is a way to isolate mass and distance from the different properties of the central object.

The event horizon sets the relevant boundary. NASA's description distinguishes material already inside it from the luminous surroundings still outside. Matter can orbit in a hot accretion disk and gradually work inward before crossing the horizon. Other light is bent into complicated paths by the surrounding gravitational field. Neither an accretion disk nor a star's orbit is situated inside the no-return region merely because it surrounds a black hole. S2's successive approaches and departures occur outside that boundary, where an orbit remains possible and its precise shape can reveal the strength and structure of gravity.

The Question

Can an object circle a black hole without falling in?

Show the answer

The Answer

Yes, an object can orbit a black hole. From far away, its gravitational field is identical to that of any other body with the same mass.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Everyone Believes’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.