A Think Again Media Group publication
Everyone Believes

Did Native Americans avoid living in what's now Yellowstone?

Yellowstone archaeology: camps, quarries, and a lake that vanished

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Everyone Believes

Yellowstone archaeology: camps, quarries, and a lake that vanished

Yellowstone archaeology includes campsites buried beside a lake that no longer exists. At Malin Creek, excavators worked through successive occupations into sediments left by an ancient lake in the Gardiner Basin. Elaine Skinner Hale, Ann Johnson, and Marie Gore describe cultural material 5.5 feet below the modern surface. They connect the site with a lake once fed by glacial runoff that extended south to two miles upstream from Gardiner, Montana. The buried occupations and lake sediments link human activity with a landscape whose water levels and shorelines have changed.

That is one part of a much larger inventory. The National Park Service's archeology overview records more than 2,000 documented sites while less than 3% of the park has been inventoried. The total includes later historic sites as well as Indigenous occupations; it is not a count of 2,000 Native villages. Much survey work has followed construction and other projects in developed areas. Yellowstone archaeology is therefore extensive but unevenly sampled. An unsurveyed mountainside and a repeatedly examined road corridor have not received equivalent scrutiny, so a simple multiplication of recorded density would not provide a reliable park-wide total.

The oldest identified objects include two Clovis-type spear points, dated by type to about 11,500–10,900 years ago, near Yellowstone Lake and the Yellowstone River. Elsewhere, successive campsites overlap through more than 9,600 years of use. Tools, manufacturing debris, and burned or butchered animal bone record particular activities. Organic objects survive less readily in acidic, thermally influenced soils, although ice patches can preserve fragile materials. These preservation differences help explain why Yellowstone archaeology contains abundant stone and fewer examples of wood, basketry, or textiles. They do not erase the occupations those more durable objects document.

Obsidian Cliff supplied one especially traceable material. The volcanic glass can be worked to a thin cutting edge, and people quarried it for toolmaking more than 11,000 years ago. The National Park Service identifies it along routes reaching western Canada, the Great Lakes, and Ohio. About 90% of the obsidian in the Hopewell mortuary sites described by the agency came from this source. That distribution establishes movement of material over long distances. It does not mean a single person walked the whole route carrying a finished object from Yellowstone to the Ohio Valley.

The quarry's physical setting preserves extraction and manufacture. In 1988, fire removed much of the plateau's forest cover and surface vegetation, exposing quarry features to survey. Investigators could examine removal from bedrock and collection of cobbles in the glacial deposits above it. Yellowstone archaeology at Obsidian Cliff consequently links distant artifacts with an actual source landscape. The cliff became a National Historic Landmark in 1996. Its value extends beyond an unusual rock exposure: quarry pits and processing locations place human work directly into the geological setting that supplied the raw material.

Nearby Nymph Lake preserves a smaller-scale working scene on thermal soils. Hale, Johnson, and Gore describe a camp dated to about 2,200 years ago, with a roasting pit, scattered fire-cracked rock, and an area of stone-tool manufacture. Well-formed flakes lay apart from poorly formed flakes struck from smaller cobbles. Notched flakes suggested an experienced toolmaker demonstrating a technique to a novice. The workshop debris is the observation; an episode of instruction is the archaeologists' interpretation of its contrasting workmanship and spatial arrangement.

Research around Yellowstone Lake adds evidence of repeated occupation and varied resource use. The Montana-Yellowstone Archaeological Project describes more than 285 sites on the shores and islands, with excavations indicating activity over about 10,000 years. A 2009 plant survey identified 52 species in a 20-acre meadow, including 15 used as foods. A stone knife near Lake Lodge tested positive for bear, cat, and deer proteins. The project's reconstruction places the lake at a meeting point of territories and travel routes, rather than at the center of a landscape used by only one group.

The same project found limits to a familiar subsistence interpretation. Investigators recovered neither native fish bones nor native-fish protein residues from the lake sites they examined. They also lacked securely identified fishing tools from the surveyed lakeshore and excavated sites, despite historical knowledge of fish in the lake. They therefore did not identify fishing as a substantial part of the prehistoric diet there. Perishable equipment and poor preservation leave possibilities open. Yellowstone archaeology supports occupation and hunting at the lake more securely than it supports every proposed explanation for why particular groups visited.

Oral traditions add another kind of evidence. Cultural resource specialist Thomas James describes a Crow man, Hunts-to-Die, recalling benevolent spirits associated with geysers, and Kiowa traditions placing a homeland among the thermal features. James contrasts those traditions with William Clark's secondhand description of avoidance; Clark himself never entered the park. These are culturally specific traditions and historical reports, rather than a survey of every individual's feelings. Alongside the camps, quarries, tools, and food remains, they show why universal avoidance is incompatible with the documented history. People used and understood different parts of this landscape in many ways.

True or False?

People universally avoided Yellowstone rather than living, hunting, or gathering there.

Show the answer

The Record

There are over 1,900 known archaeological sites inside the park—and that's from surveying only 3% of it. People have hunted, gathered, and lived in this landscape for more than 11,500 years. Sure, they probably feared cold, predators, and lean winters like anyone else—but not the place itself. Yellowstone wasn't a haunted no-man's-land; it was home. The archaeological record could extend to tens of thousands of sites.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Everyone Believes’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.